Can a Building Complete an Elevator Modernization Bid Themselves?

In the complex world of building management, modernizing an elevator is often seen as a complex crucial task. While some building owners and managers might consider handling the bid process themselves. To save costs, the intricacies involved typically make this a challenging endeavor. Exploring the feasibility of a DIY approach to elevator modernization bids is common among many owners. Some have success and some do not. 

Can a Building Complete an Elevator Modernization Bid Themselves?

The Complexity of Elevator Modernization

Elevator modernization is a multifaceted process that involves upgrading or replacing critical components. Such as controllers, machines, and doors to enhance performance, safety, and compliance with current regulations. This process is not just about swapping out old parts for new ones. It requires a deep understanding of the building’s needs. The current condition of the elevator system components, and technical specifications. Safety standards, and regulatory requirements that govern the building’s elevator systems.

The Expertise Gap

Most building owners and managers are not elevator experts. The technical jargon and intricate details involved in elevator modernization can be overwhelming. For instance, understanding whether a door package is included, if the machine will be reused or refurbished, or if the equipment will be proprietary or non-proprietary are crucial aspects that require specialized knowledge. Without this expertise, it is challenging to ensure that the bids received are comprehensive and comparable.

Key Considerations for DIY Modernization Bids

1. Technical Expertise:

  •    In-Depth Knowledge: Understanding the specific needs of the building, the type of elevator and the requirements of the local code. This technical expertise is crucial for drafting a comprehensive bid.
  •    Compliance and Safety Standards: Adhering to the latest safety standards and relevant codes is non-negotiable.

2. Vendor Selection and Management:

  •  Evaluating Proposals: Even if a building owner drafts the bid, evaluating the proposals received from various vendors requires a nuanced understanding of what each offer entails. This includes assessing the quality of materials, the comprehensiveness of the work scope, and the reliability of the vendor.
  • Inconsistent Bids: When building owners solicit bids from multiple elevator service providers, the proposals often vary significantly in scope and pricing. This inconsistency can lead to confusion and make it difficult to compare bids effectively
  • Hidden Costs: Elevator modernization bids can sometimes include hidden or unnecessary costs. Without the expertise to identify these, building owners may end up overpaying for services or equipment that are not essential

The Role of Elevator Consultants

Hiring an elevator consultant can mitigate many of the risks associated with DIY modernization bids. These experts bring a wealth of knowledge and experience, providing valuable services such as:

Unbiased Assessments

Unlike vendors, consultants have no financial stake in selling specific equipment or services. They provide objective evaluations tailored to the building’s unique needs

Project Management

Consultants manage the entire process from start to finish, ensuring that timelines are met and that the work adheres to the highest standards

Comprehensive Assessment

An elevator consultant conducts a thorough assessment of the existing elevator system to determine the exact needs for modernization. This includes evaluating the condition of the equipment, identifying necessary upgrades, and ensuring compliance with safety codes.

Detailed Specifications

Consultants prepare detailed specifications for the project, ensuring that all necessary work is included and that the bids received are comparable. This helps in eliminating change orders and unexpected costs down the line.

Bid Management

Consultants manage the entire bidding process, from soliciting bids to evaluating proposals and negotiating with contractors. This ensures that the building receives the best value for its investment and that the project is completed on time and within budget.

Project Oversight

Throughout the modernization process, consultants provide ongoing oversight to ensure that the work is performed to the highest standards. This includes regular inspections, progress reports, and final acceptance checks to ensure that the upgraded elevator system meets all performance and safety criteria.

Long-Term Savings

By ensuring the right upgrades are made and preventing unnecessary expenditures, consultants can save buildings significant amounts in the long run

While it’s theoretically possible for a building to handle an elevator modernization bid themselves, the practical challenges often outweigh the benefits. The process demands a high level of technical knowledge, effective vendor management, and strategic financial planning—areas where the expertise of an elevator consultant proves invaluable. Engaging a consultant not only ensures compliance and safety but also provides long-term cost savings and peace of mind, making it a wise investment for any building owner or manager facing the daunting task of elevator modernization.

Have a Question About Elevators Consultants?


(312) 519-9949

FAQs about Elevator Modernization

« Prev Blog Post Next Blog Post »